Who's to Blame When AI Makes a Medical Error?

Assistive artificial intelligence technologies hold significant promise for transforming health care by aiding physicians in diagnosing, managing, and treating patients. However, the current trend of assistive AI implementation could actually worsen challenges related to error prevention and physician burnout, according to a new brief published in JAMA Health Forum.

The brief, written by researchers from the Johns Hopkins Carey Business School, Johns Hopkins Medicine, and The University of Texas at Austin McCombs School of Business, explains that there is an increasing expectation of physicians to rely on AI to minimize medical errors. However, proper laws and regulations are not yet in place to support physicians as they make AI-guided decisions, despite the fierce adoption of these technologies among health care organizations.

The researchers predict that medical liability will depend on whom society considers at fault when the technology fails or makes a mistake, subjecting physicians to an unrealistic expectation of knowing when to override or trust AI. The authors warn that such an expectation could increase the risk of burnout and even errors among physicians.

"AI was meant to ease the burden, but instead, it’s shifting liability onto physicians - forcing them to flawlessly interpret technology even its creators can’t fully explain," said Shefali Patil, visiting associate professor at the Carey Business School and associate professor at the University of Texas McCombs School of Business. "This unrealistic expectation creates hesitation and poses a direct threat to patient care."

The new brief suggests strategies for health care organizations to support physicians by shifting the focus from individual performance to organizational support and learning, which may alleviate pressure on physicians and foster a more collaborative approach to AI integration.

"Expecting physicians to perfectly understand and apply AI alone when making clinical decisions is like expecting pilots to also design their own aircraft - while they’re flying it," said Christopher Myers, associate professor and faculty director of the Center for Innovative Leadership at the Carey Business School. "To ensure AI empowers rather than exhausts physicians, health care organizations must develop support systems that help physicians calibrate when and how to use AI so they don’t need to second-guess the tools they’re using to make key decisions."

Patil SV, Myers CG, Lu-Myers Y.
Calibrating AI Reliance-A Physician's Superhuman Dilemma.
JAMA Health Forum. 2025 Mar 7;6(3):e250106. doi: 10.1001/jamahealthforum.2025.0106

Most Popular Now

Mobile App Tracking Blood Pressure Helps…

The AHOMKA platform, an innovative mobile app for patient-to-provider communication that developed through a collaboration between the School of Engineering and leading medical institutions in Ghana, has yielded positive results...

Can AI Help Detect Cognitive Impairment?

Mild cognitive impairment (MCI) can be an early indicator of Alzheimer's disease or dementia, so identifying those with cognitive issues early could lead to interventions and better outcomes. But diagnosing...

Accelerating NHS Digital Maturity: Paper…

Digitised clinical noting at South Tees Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust is creating efficiencies for busy doctors and nurses. The trust’s CCIO Dr Andrew Adair, deputy CCIO Dr John Greenaway, and...

Customized Smartphone App Shows Promise …

A growing body of research indicates that older adults in assisted living facilities can delay or even prevent cognitive decline through interventions that combine multiple activities, such as improving diet...

New Study Shows Promise for Gamified mHe…

A new study published in Multiple Sclerosis and Related Disorders highlights the potential of More Stamina, a gamified mobile health (mHealth) app designed to help people with Multiple Sclerosis (MS)...

AI Tool Helps Predict Who will Benefit f…

A study led by UCLA investigators shows that artificial intelligence (AI) could play a key role in improving treatment outcomes for men with prostate cancer by helping physicians determine who...

Patients' Affinity for AI Messages …

In a Duke Health-led survey, patients who were shown messages written either by artificial intelligence (AI) or human clinicians indicated a preference for responses drafted by AI over a human...

New Research Explores How AI can Build T…

In today’s economy, many workers have transitioned from manual labor toward knowledge work, a move driven primarily by technological advances, and workers in this domain face challenges around managing non-routine...

AI in Healthcare: How do We Get from Hyp…

The Highland Marketing advisory board met to consider the government's enthusiasm for AI. To date, healthcare has mostly experimented with decision support tools, and their impact on the NHS and...

Research Shows AI Technology Improves Pa…

Existing research indicates that the accuracy of a Parkinson's disease diagnosis hovers between 55% and 78% in the first five years of assessment. That's partly because Parkinson's sibling movement disorders...

New AI Tool Accelerates Disease Treatmen…

University of Virginia School of Medicine scientists have created a computational tool to accelerate the development of new disease treatments. The tool goes beyond current artificial intelligence (AI) approaches by...

DMEA sparks: The Future of Digital Healt…

8 - 10 April 2025, Berlin, Germany. Digitalization is considered one of the key strategies for addressing the shortage of skilled workers - but the digital health sector also needs qualified...