The Public Needs to be Onboard for Vaccine Passport Journey

Opinion Article by David Newell, Head of Health, Gemserv
Anyone who's ever misplaced their passport will recognise that moment of panic. Anxious thoughts descend, thinking you’ll miss that flight or be stuck abroad - until you find that little burgundy or blue book hiding where you last left it.

Anxiety of a different kind is now on the horizon thanks to a different kind of passport. Last week, the European Union (EU) laid out why COVID-19 passports are critical to saving the economies of southern Europe, allowing those who have been vaccinated to return to the beaches of the Mediterranean this summer.

The UK Government has signalled its support for the approach and said it was working with the EU to shape the necessary protocols. Like it or not, vaccine passports in some form or other are on their way.

The concept behind such passports is simple, but the ethical and privacy issues are highly complex. While anyone who has travelled to Brazil will be familiar with the yellow fever vaccine and certificate required, any Covid-19 document will have much wider implications.

While diseases such as yellow fever are confined to specific regions, Covid-19 is everywhere. Vaccine passports put those who opted not to receive the vaccine at a disadvantage - will they be barred from holidaying in Spain or Greece or Cyprus this summer, and potentially for many summers to come?

Passport debate just beginning

Gemserv recently attended an All-Party Parliamentary Group (APPG) for Foreign Affairs online roundtable where vaccine minister Nadhim Zahawi provided an update on COVID-19 vaccine deployment and using the UK’s surplus vaccines as part of our international aid programme.

There were many positive developments discussed at the meeting and the minister outlined some of the critical next steps towards recovery from the pandemic.

I was delighted to learn more about the UK Government's approach to the longer-term recovery, including:

  • support for domestic manufacturing capability, which will drive longer-term investment into the British pharmaceuticals and biotechnology industry;
  • increasing capability for gene sequencing to spot variants, an area in which the UK already leads the world;
  • and new innovations, including a combined flu and Covid-19 vaccine and mRNA production.

Much positive progress is clearly being made around the whole vaccine agenda, but we're still at the early stages of the debate on passports.

It's about more than holidays

For example, arguments will arise over whether anyone has a "right" to a foreign holiday. While some people will have chosen not to be vaccinated against Covid-19, others will have been unable to be inoculated for health reasons beyond their control.

Away from the travel implications, the concept of a domestic vaccination passport raises different ethical questions. Could pubs refuse entry to potential customers who can't prove they’ve had the jab?

How about "no jab, no job"? the fact Charlie Mullins the CEO of Pimlico Plumbers is planning on introducing a no jab no job clause into new joiners contracts is widely covered in the press, but how about care workers and NHS staff?

Some commentators have cited the precedent of healthcare workers already requiring certain immunisations. For example, surgeons, theatre nurses, and other medics likely to come into contact with patients' blood must be given a hepatitis B jab.

Yet whether someone could be rejected for employment because they have refused - or were unable to receive – the vaccine raises wider ethical questions. These are serious issues, which require open and transparent debate.

Privacy lessons must be learned

I welcome the fact this topic is being given appropriate attention and consideration. Prime Minister Boris Johnson has tasked cabinet minister Michael Gove with leading a review into the possible use of vaccine certificates - or domestic vaccine passports - for businesses in the UK.

One lesson that we have to learn from earlier in the pandemic - particularly from launch of the tracing app in England - is that ethics and privacy need to be front and centre in this debate. If we don't consider those twin topics then we will end up with a white elephant, with no public support and a knock-on delay to our economic recovery.

As we also have learned during this pandemic, we cannot separate health from wealth. Wealth is one of the factors that determines health - whether it's at a personal level through access to a healthy diet or at a societal level when it comes to paying for services to keep them free at the point of care.

Getting the ethical and data privacy issues surrounding vaccine passports right will have a profound impact on the economy and, in turn, on our medium-term mental health and our long-term wellness. That's why this debate is about far more than a trip to sunny Spain.

Most Popular Now

Most Advanced Artificial Touch for Brain…

For the first time ever, a complex sense of touch for individuals living with spinal cord injuries is a step closer to reality. A new study published in Science, paves...

Predicting the Progression of Autoimmune…

Autoimmune diseases, where the immune system mistakenly attacks the body's own healthy cells and tissues, often have a preclinical stage before diagnosis that’s characterized by mild symptoms or certain antibodies...

Major EU Project to Investigate Societal…

A new €3 million EU research project led by University College Dublin (UCD) Centre for Digital Policy will explore the benefits and risks of Artificial Intelligence (AI) from a societal...

Using AI to Uncover Hospital Patients�…

Across the United States, no hospital is the same. Equipment, staffing, technical capabilities, and patient populations can all differ. So, while the profiles developed for people with common conditions may...

New AI Tool Uses Routine Blood Tests to …

Doctors around the world may soon have access to a new tool that could better predict whether individual cancer patients will benefit from immune checkpoint inhibitors - a type of...

New Method Tracks the 'Learning Cur…

Introducing Annotatability - a powerful new framework to address a major challenge in biological research by examining how artificial neural networks learn to label genomic data. Genomic datasets often contain...

Picking the Right Doctor? AI could Help

Years ago, as she sat in waiting rooms, Maytal Saar-Tsechansky began to wonder how people chose a good doctor when they had no way of knowing a doctor's track record...

From Text to Structured Information Secu…

Artificial intelligence (AI) and above all large language models (LLMs), which also form the basis for ChatGPT, are increasingly in demand in hospitals. However, patient data must always be protected...

AI Innovation Unlocks Non-Surgical Way t…

Researchers have developed an artificial intelligence (AI) model to detect the spread of metastatic brain cancer using MRI scans, offering insights into patients’ cancer without aggressive surgery. The proof-of-concept study, co-led...

Deep Learning Model Helps Detect Lung Tu…

A new deep learning model shows promise in detecting and segmenting lung tumors, according to a study published in Radiology, a journal of the Radiological Society of North America (RSNA)...

One of the Largest Global Surveys of Soc…

As leaders gather for the World Economic Forum Annual Meeting 2025 in Davos, Leaps by Bayer, the impact investing arm of Bayer, and Boston Consulting Group (BCG) announced the launch...

New Study Reveals AI's Transformati…

Intensive care units (ICUs) face mounting pressure to effectively manage resources while delivering optimal patient care. Groundbreaking research published in the INFORMS journal Information Systems Research highlights how a novel...